clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

The Daily Chop: New format coming to MLB postseason?

New, 142 comments

The league office has reportedly been considering a major shakeup to the postseason format as it currently stands.

2019 NLDS Game 1 - St. Louis Cardinals v. Atlanta Braves Photo by Mike Zarrilli/MLB Photos via Getty Images

Reports surfaced on Monday that Major League Baseball is considering a sweeping change to its current postseason format. The league famously added a Wild Card game in each league for the 2012 season, which ultimately had a major effect on the Braves as they lost to the Cardinals at home to end their season. Eight years later, the league has reportedly tossed around the following possibilities:

  • Seven playoff teams in each league
  • Elimination of Wild Card Game
  • Best-of-three round consisting of the two lower-ranked division winners and four Wild Card teams
  • Teams in Wild Card round choose opponents in descending order, starting with highest seed
  • Higher-ranked teams host all three games in Wild Card round

This proposal is certain to draw strong opposition, just as the Wild Card Game did eight years ago. This plan is very radical in terms of impact compared to the adoption of the Wild Card Game. The randomness of postseason baseball is already a mild deterrent to the aggressive pursuit of a fully fortified roster, which would become an even greater concern with an added round of three. The Trade Deadline would, however, become almost non-existent as teams hold serve for the possibility of sneaking into the postseason.

The impact across the league would be sizable, and would alter the scope of teams dramatically throughout the season. Transforming the Wild Card Game into a Wild Card Series is a noble concept, but adding two more teams and three more series to each league seems like a recipe for absolute chaos. While chaos may be an enticing concept, it would seriously damage the value of the regular season. Winning the division would have meaning, but it would be diminished severely. This is an extremely polarizing topic, so what are your thoughts?

Braves News

Inbox: Will Braves move to counter LA’s trade?

Mark Bowman answers fan questions as the Braves prepare for the reporting of pitchers and catchers to Spring Training.

Atlanta Braves Spring Training Preview: Catchers

Kris continues his rundown of Braves position groups, with this iteration focusing on the catchers. The addition of Travis d’Arnaud could be a major boost to a position that was middling last season.

MLB News

Pederson trade to Angels is off, Eppler says

Pederson certainly has his shortcomings, but did produce a 138 wRC+ against RHPs in 2019. He will be a popular trade target for any team in need of left-handed power.

Mookie’s in LA. Are one of these 5 moves next?

The Braves are mentioned in connection with Nolan Arenado and Kris Bryant, though neither are projected to Atlanta in this hypothetical.

Houston may have found its next Cuban star

The Astros ruined the sanctity of baseball for the past three years, yet are still allowed to sign the top international free agent on the market. What a wonderful environment commissioner Rob Manfred has cultivated.

Yelich, Acuña or Trout for No. 1 fantasy pick?

Who is your top pick for 2020?