Sickels Releases Top-20 Braves Prospects for 2009
We get our first top prospect list of the year from one of the major prospect outlets. John Sickels has been putting out prospect books for over six years now, where he reviews prospect from every organization, over 1000 prospects all together. His 2009 prospect book is available for pre-order here, and is well worth buying.
The following are his "extrememly preliminary" prospect rankings for the 2009 Braves prospects:
- Jason Heyward, OF, Grade A-: A personal favorite, though he actually hit fewer homers than expected. Broad base of skills.
- Frederick Freeman, 1B, Grade B+: Debating whether or not to move him up to A-. Not as broad a skill base as Heyward, but power and youth stand out.
- Thomas Hanson, RHP, Grade B+: Looks good to me, though will need some Triple-A to put on the finishing touches. Number Two starter ceiling.
- Jordan Schafer, OF, Grade B+: I should have put him on the Rotowire Top 100 list. Will be in the 50/50 for the book. Power, speed, defense, OBP, and played well without the juice.
- Tyler Flowers, C, Grade B: Love the power and walks, main question is glove.
- Cole Rohrbough, LHP, Grade B: Excellent ceiling. I cannot prove why objectively, but I worry a bit about his arm. Needs sharper command too.
- Craig Kimbrel, RHP, Grade B: I hesitate to grade relief prospects this highly, but I can’t ignore his early dominance.
- Gorkys Hernandez, OF, Grade B-: Would like to see more power, other skills coming along.
- Kris Medlen, RHP, Grade B-: Am I overrating him? Looks like he could be a really good swingman.
- Jeff Locke, LHP, Grade B-: I’ve liked him since he was in high school. Like Rohrbough, worry some about injuries.
- Randall Delgado, RHP, Grade B-: Needs better command, but a high ceiling guy.
- Brett DeVall, LHP, Grade B-: A long way away, but a high ceiling.
- Zeke Spruill, RHP, Grade B-: Like DeVall, a long way off, but fits into organization philosophy perfectly.
- Brandon Hicks, SS, Grade C+: Love the power, walks, speed, defense. Hate the strikeouts.
- Eric Campbell, 3B, Grade C+: If his head is on straight, could surprise people in ’09.
- James Parr, RHP, Grade C+: Fourth/fifth starter type.
- J.J. Hoover, RHP, Grade C+: Sleeper call on a junior college guy that I love. Hard-thrower with improving command.
- Kala Ka’aihue, 1B, Grade C+: Similar to his brother Kila though I don’t think he will perform quite as well in ’09 as his brother did in ’08.
- David Francis, RHP, Grade C+: Sleeper pick.
- Edgar Osuna, LHP, Grade C+: Sleeper pick, great K/BB ratio.
The biggest surprise here is listing Randall Delgado over Julio Teheran. He does mention JT as a C+ prospect, and I suppose there are more games played to evaluate Delgado than there are for Teheran.
He lists five guys from this year's draft, with Craig Kimbrel getting a very high grade. It's great to see 12 prospects getting a B-something grade -- Sickels doesn't give those out lightly; and of course I expect to see the A- Jason Heyward grabbing the top spot in all of these lists.
0 recs |
12 comments
Comments
My list
I like to base my list on who I think will be the biggest impact guy. An untradeable guy. I wouldn’t rank KK in the top 20 because he is already a really high strikeout guy in AA so he probably won’t ever make the Majors. Cody Johnson still has time though.
1. Julio Teheran (Potential Ace based on how he bounces back mentally)
2. Jason Heyward (Future AS at a premium power position)
3. Jordan Schafer (Future AS at a premium position)
4. Tommy Hanson (Definite #2 guy with great attitude)
5. Gorkys Hernandez (ML starter at a premium position)
6. Freddy Freeman (If his D is not hyped then he is a solid ML’er)
7. Jeff Locke (Definite #2 guy)
8. Cole Rohrbough (Potential #2)
9. Kris Medlen (solid #3 or #4 guy with great attitude. Problem is I can’t think of one ML starter that is a physical comp (5-9, 170) for him)
10. Eric Campbell (Potential AS, but apparent headcase so he drops from top 5)
11. Brandon Hicks (ML shortstop no doubt)
12. Brett DeVall (potential #4 or #5 guy)
13. John Gilmore (fringe ML’er who reminds me of Todd Zeile kinda)
14. Edgar Osuna (Fringe ML’er)
15. Eric Cordier (if he bounces back from injury he is a top 10 for us IMO)
16. James Parr (proved he can handle back of rotation. Will get hit hard every time out.)
17. Scott Diamond (big year for the future rotation guy)
18. Travis Jones (good leader, fringe ML’er)
19. Francisley Bueno (homegrown LOOGY…don’t laugh that’s valuable man)
20. Steve Evarts (Potential #3 but apparent headcase so he drops IMO)
21. Cody Johnson (I trust our scouts for taking him in 1st round)
Todd Redmond is awesome and he battles a lot like Parr. I don’t like Flowers or Britton or any of our other catchers. Good thing we have Sammons. Lillibridge is a super-utility guy to me which is not as good as a fringe ML’er by my reasoning. Should I put Sumoza in there? Marek is overrated to me. He’s ok I guess. I love some of the recent Dominican players we’ve signed like Carlos Perez. What about the Aussie Steve Kent?
by themurph on Oct 23, 2008 8:23 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Lincencum isn’t much bigger than Medlen.
by cbwilk on Oct 24, 2008 3:40 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
My Problem
with Kris Medlen is that I can think of a physical comp all to easily. Mike Hampton. With that said, Hampton was actually pretty durable for awhile, so make of it what you will.
by OldDutchPots on Oct 24, 2008 7:38 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Where did you hear that Evarts is a headcase…I just thought he had TJS last season??? I kinda like your philosophy, especially with Flowers (who we should trade while we can), but you need Kimbrel in there.
by bwellnjonesco on Oct 24, 2008 8:21 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Evarts has been arrested at least once.
by 17843 on Oct 24, 2008 10:56 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
themurph, Flwoers isn’t in your top 20? what the hell? and why isnt Teheran in Sickels list.
by SayHeyWerd on Oct 23, 2008 8:28 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Flowers
I just don’t like Flowers as a potential impact player at catcher or first base. I think of Ryan Shealy everytime. Flowers’ swing can get a little long at times and I have a hard time believing he is going to be a catcher.
Where would put him?
by themurph on Oct 23, 2008 9:18 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Flowers
I would probably put Flowers ahead of Kimbrel and behind Rohrbough. Can’t ignore the power and walks.
by SayHeyWerd on Oct 24, 2008 3:02 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Freeman and Delgado so high is ridiculous.
by 17843 on Oct 23, 2008 9:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Personally...
I would give Hanson an A-. Excellent numbers in the high minors, classic pitcher’s build and a power arsenal. He does need a little AAA seasoning, but that could well be 5-10 starts before he gets the call to Atlanta.
Freeman surprises me a little in that he’s ranked higher than Flowers, Schafer, and the aformentioned Hanson, but his power does seem to be very real.
by BraveBronco0121 on Oct 23, 2008 10:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Freeman too high?
I’m not sure where this is coming from. All the guy did was hit .315 with 18 homers in the exact same league as Jason Heyward, who hit .324 with 11 homers. And Freeman is a month younger so age can’t play a factor either. I don’t hear anyone complaining about Heyward being too high.
by ajones2522 on Oct 23, 2008 11:57 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
No, defensive position certainly plays a big factor. Freeman has to have a pretty damn good bat to project as a better prospect than Schafer or Hanson, especially considering his level. Heyward doesn’t have the same expectations as a right fielder. You really have to believe in a 19 year old bat that’s never hit outside of Low A-ball to rate Freeman where he is.
by 17843 on Oct 24, 2008 12:17 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 












