I will give the answer after some responses. But both of these guys are everyday players and yes they have to be in the lineup every day. So by looking at the stats who would you rather have.
#1-.215/.296/.425/.722 17 HR 46 RBI 41BB 119K
#2-.212/.282/.417/.699 23 HR 52 RBI 99K 37BB
And remember one of these guys has to be your everyday player and both of these guys are currently everyday players