A mostly unbiased all-star ballot...

I know there was probably a collective eye roll upon the posting of this fanpost. Really, I wanted to do some research for myself so I could make informed decisions for the all-star game. As much as I hate that the starters are supposed to be voted on by fans, I don't want to be one of those fans that just votes for his/her favorites or the most popular.

You may wonder why I have only listed these simple stats for each player. The reason for this is that I think they are mostly indicative of the level at which the players have played thus far. Most of the advanced stats don't really tell a different story than these.

The players aren't listed in any type of order and I may have left off a few players who you think are deserving, but I'm certainly still open for debate on which players are truly deserving.

Here we go!


Doumit: OBP: .363 / OPS: .813 / XBH: 15 / RBI: 19 / R: 14

Barajas: OBP: .293 / OPS: .832 / XBH: 18 / RBI: 28 / R: 21

McCann: OBP: .383 / OPS: .811 / XBH: 12 / RBI: 18 / R: 18

Ruiz: OBP: .426 / OPS: .820 / XBH: 7 / RBI: 11 / R: 13

Hernandez: OBP: .412 / OPS: .861 / XBH: 9 / RBI: 12 / R: 10

I think the catching position is probably one of the hardest to really gauge. The reason I chose OBP instead of AVG for the catchers was because of the large discrepancies between the candidates. Some catchers have a high average and a comparatively low on-base and vice versa. Considering the rough start McCann had, I was pleasantly surprised by his numbers. Objectively, I would choose Doumit. Ruiz has had a solid season to this point. Ramon Hernandez’s numbers trump Doumit’s, but he has been splitting time with Hannigan. The Reds catching duo is off to a hot start and are trying to overtake the McCann/Ross duo for tops in the NL.


Votto: AVG: .312 / OPS: .961 / XBH: 20 / RBI: 33 / R: 29

Pujols: AVG: .299 / OPS: .925 / XBH: 22 / RBI: 34 / R: 27

Howard: AVG: .291 / OPS: .804 / XBH: 16 / RBI: 33 / R: 29

Huff: AVG: .291 / OPS: .826 / XBH: 16 / RBI: 22 / R: 25

Fielder: AVG: .268 / OPS: .826 / XBH: 14 / RBI: 19 / R: 31

Votto has gotten off to a great start while Pujols has had an unusually poor month of May. I honestly don’t think you could go wrong by choosing either Votto or Pujols, but thus far the nod should go to Votto. Howard, Huff and Fielder are having good seasons, too, but they don’t really compare with the top two first sackers.


Utley: AVG: .276 / OPS: .919 / XBH: 21 / RBI: 24 / R: 35

Prado: AVG: .324 / OPS: .824 / XBH: 19 / RBI: 26 / R: 36

Uggla: AVG: .267 / OPS: .876 / XBH: 21 / RBI: 31 / R: 34

Johnson: AVG: .253 / OPS: .910 / XBH: 27 / RBI: 25 / R: 32

Fontenot: AVG: .337 / OPS: .886 / XBH: 12 / RBI: 15 / R: 11

Remember when the NL East used to be known for all their great shortstops? The tide seems to have turned to the right side of the infield and the new beasts of the east are the second basemen. Despite my bias, I can see that Utley is having another great season. I was surprised by how closely his numbers compare with Prado's, Uggla's and Johnson's. The NL Team would do well to have both Utley and Prado make the team. Unfortunately for Uggla, I still have nightmares (ok, that’s an exaggeration…) of his last all-star errorfest appearance, so I’ll probably never vote for him. Johnson, however, is having a great year; he has really been racking up the extra-base hits.


Zimmerman: AVG: .295 / OPS: .910 / XBH: 20 / RBI: 25 / R: 25

Wright: AVG: .244 / OPS: .811 / XBH: 21 / RBI: 33 / R: 21

McGehee: AVG: .308 / OPS: .896 / XBH: 22 / RBI: 41 / R: 25

Rolen: AVG: .277 / OPS: .900 / XBH: 22 / RBI: 32 / R: 28

Polanco: AVG: .306 / OPS: .790 / XBH: 16 / RBI: 21 / R: 26

I was surprised by the overall lack of production out of 3B this season. McGehee, Rolen and Zimmerman seem to be standing head and toes above the rest of the pack. Zimmerman and Rolen are both great defensively as well as offensively. What separates the two are their teams; the Reds are having a great season while the Nationals are hovering around .500. Both seem to be equally important to their teams, but since Rolen’s team has had more success it would make sense to vote for the more successful player.


Ramirez: AVG: .297 / OPS: .857 / XBH: 17 / RBI: 26 / R: 26

Tulowitzki: AVG: .306 / OPS: .865 / XBH: 21 / RBI: 25 / R: 38

Drew: AVG: .299 / OPS: .847 / XBH: 20 / RBI: 19 / R: 28

Uribe: AVG: .286 / OPS: .830 / XBH: 14 / RBI: 29 / R: 22

Rollins: Irrelevant at this point…

Shortstop is another competitive position, though it is much more top-heavy than 2B. Tulowitzki is deserving of the start; he’s great on both sides of the ball. Ramirez and Drew are also having excellent seasons, and since when does Juan Uribe deserve all-star consideration? Rollins would be having a great year if he could stay on the field. Alas, the nod goes to Tulo.


Heyward AVG: .298 / OPS: 1.011 / XBH: 22 /RBI: 36 / R: 29

Braun AVG: .325 / OPS: .932 / XBH: 24 / RBI: 32 / R: 38

Werth AVG: .302 / OPS: .968 / XBH: 31 / RBI: 31 / R: 31

Willingham AVG: .280 / OPS: .973 / XBH: 18 / RBI: 34 / R: 29

Soriano AVG: .301 / OPS: .951 / XBH: 25 / RBI: 27 / R: 28

Victorino AVG: .257 / OPS: .769 / XBH: 19 / RBI: 33 / R: 29

This is where it really gets tough. There are many outfielders who are very deserving of an all-star selection. I left off several worthy candidates, most notably Andrew McCutchen, Andre Ethier, and Melky Cabrera. Since Melky was left off the ballot, however, the three players who are most deserving are Werth, Heyward and Braun. That might be an…interesting outfield considering they’re all corner men. If I were to pick an actual LF, CF and RF, I would probably choose Braun, McCutchen and Heyward. Why Heyward over Werth, you ask? Simple. It’s because of Heyward’s flair for the dramatic…nothing to do with my Braves bias, I swear.

Since I'm nice I will provide the cliffnotes version...

C: Doumit

1B: Votto

2B: Prado

3B: Rolen

SS: Tulowitzki

OF: Werth

OF: Heyward

OF: Braun

Some of these are bound to change (i.e. Doumit to McCann), but at this point I think these players are deserving of All-Star starts. Do you agree or disagree?

Stats provided by ESPN.

This FanPost does not express the views or opinions of Talking Chop.

Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Talking Chop

You must be a member of Talking Chop to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Talking Chop. You should read them.

Join Talking Chop

You must be a member of Talking Chop to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Talking Chop. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.