The NL Needs the DH
A number of current MLB controversies have made it clear that the game is moving forward into a new era. One fan tries to find the best balance between past and present.
From http://www.splicetoday.com/sports/the-nl-needs-the-dh
Baseball is an exhilarating yet frustrating mess of contradictions, and this fan is caught in the trap—like millions of other men and women (save George Will, whose pompous moral certitude about the sport is immutable)—of trying to reconcile “purist” instincts with the undeniable improvements in the game over the past several decades. Last weekend, for example, while watching a slew of inter-league contests via the MLB “Extra Innings” package (which, regardless of varying prices depending on your locale and cable provider, costs less for an entire season of televised games than one day at a stadium for a family of four), I finally switched gears and figured it was time for the National League to acquiesce and adopt the still-controversial designated hitter rule.
Heresy, I guess, but what the hell; if you’re a Milwaukee Brewers’ devotee, wouldn’t it be delightful to see the world’s tubbiest vegetarian, Prince Fielder, in the dugout, contemplating his next plate appearance, instead of anchored at first base? One league’s dominance over the other usually runs in cycles, but the N.L. seems mired in a slump that’s likely to run longer than the Great Depression, and this was evident once again over the weekend. Sure, the strategy required of an N.L. manager is more intricate than A.L. counterparts with double-switches and more sacrifice bunts, but the two leagues might be more competitive if older free agents (or crummy fielders) could extend their careers as a DH.
That said, and here’s one of those curveballs, I can’t stand inter-league play, even though it pumps up attendance and allows fans to see star players who were once a mystery aside from the All-Star game (which, of course, has devolved into a meaningless exhibition game instead of a proud showcase) or the World Series. My 13-year-old son, with whom I have the pleasure of sitting next to in our matching easy chairs in the homestead’s television room, adamantly disagrees, but I chalk that up to his participation in a fantasy league with a bunch of school buddies. I just don’t like the disruption of the season’s rhythm, the fake “rivalries” cooked up by MLB schedule makers—sure, the Cubs and White Sox make sense, but the Rockies and Tigers?—for the sake of novelty and profit.
See the rest at http://www.splicetoday.com/sports/the-nl-needs-the-dh
This FanPost does not express the views or opinions of Talking Chop.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Personally, I like NL-style ball better.
Just my preference. I like the strategy, and I feel that it rewards deeper teams (the need for a deep bullpen, effective pinch hitters, and a versatile bench).
No it doesn't.
By the way, you forgot to join the Marlins SBNation blog in the last 20 minutes, to shill this article onto.
No wonder nobody likes you, Tuttle... everything's a (Pujols) damn debate.
Great idea...
...let’s put training wheels on the NL too!
I'm gettin' out of this town alive...even if it kills me.
Actually...
It makes just as much sense, if not more, to simply eliminate the DH rule in the AL. American League games are boring; their managers could turn in their line-up cards and go home, with the pitching coaches handling any bullpen action. I’d rather watch starters battle to extend a start in order to better use a pinch hitter or the use of a double-switch in the event that he can’t than old sluggers that can’t field extended their careers as designated hitters. I’m sure the next advance will come in basketball, when the designated free throw shooter will make Shaq-like players truly unstoppable. Progress!
Please check out my blog at http://thefulldeck.blogspot.com/ , now redesigned and recommited!
You’re completely right, but it’s funny how we never hear this alternative. I suppose it’s because HR = $, or because the Yankees and Red Sox are the most important teams in the MLB.
I'm gettin' out of this town alive...even if it kills me.
by Smoltz's Beard on Jul 1, 2008 11:08 AM EDT up reply actions
I think...
the AL managers could turn in their lineup cards and go get a beer while a pitching machine throws and you treat the game like a home run derby. Saves Steinbrenner lots of money buying pitchers (beers and throwers) and the players don’t have to run the bases or anything. To me, that’s AL baseball now.
+1
I'm gettin' out of this town alive...even if it kills me.
by Smoltz's Beard on Jul 1, 2008 11:06 AM EDT up reply actions
...and David Ortiz, Jim Thome, Hideki Matsui, Jose Vidro, Gary Sheffield, and Frank Thomas are all Olympic-caliber base runners, and the 100-or-so other hits they have that aren’t home runs result in some graceful, hippopotamus-in-the-water American League excitement. Pujols, I wish we had that in the National League…
No wonder nobody likes you, Tuttle... everything's a (Pujols) damn debate.
Thoughts on DH
One thing that I’ve always wondered about the DH is why limit it to pitchers? For instance, if a team has Micah Owings and, say, Corky Miller as catcher, could the team DH for Corky, as Owings has proven to be a far superior hitter than Corky? Why not? Isn’t that what the DH is for anyway? Get rid of bad hitters in favor of more exciting hitters?
What would be even MORE exciting, however, is just to do like football, have separate players on offense and defense! That way, players can focus on only one skill. I mean, what does hitting have in common with fielding anyway? If players focused on only fielding, how many more spectacular plays would there be? And, all each team would need is only four hitters, so think about the best four hitters on each team hitting over and over and over! How exciting would that be?! No need to pinch-hit anymore either, with such quality bats!
Ridiculous? Of course it is! And that’s what happens when we do things for the sake of “excitement!” If you like the DH, go watch a softball game.
I like what they do or used to do in College...
...I’m not sure how much of a practice it is now. But when John Olerud was pitching for Washington State, he used to be the DH/Pitcher. So if he came out of a game while he was pitching, he was still able to remain as the teams DH.
Good Point
Speaking of college ball, aluminum bats would make the NL more exciting, too. Anyone want to start using them?
DH or no DH...
...very little in the game of baseball is more exciting or breath-taking than watching a pitcher dominate the opposition, locked in, and mowing down batter after batter after batter.
No wonder nobody likes you, Tuttle... everything's a (Pujols) damn debate.
ditto
my only game at the Ted (ever) was a 1-0 (or maybe 2-1) loss to the D-backs. Worst game ever to see for your only experience at the Ecuadorian-heat, steamy Braves home, right?
WRONG!!!!
It was a Schilling-Maddux duel, both pitchers going late and doing great. AJ made a fanTASTIC assist to get a runner at home, and that was an easy second to seeing just how quickly both Schill and Madd-dog ate up the batters. Javy was embarrassing, Chip was probably injured, and AJ couldnt get anything done. Awesome. But too short.
similar story i was at the Ted and saw Smoltz and Ben Sheets duel for a 2-1 Braves victory, in which this guy that used to play for us… Jeff Francoeur, hit a game winning double in the 9th
"The game doesn't stink Mr. Wheeler. It's a GREAT GAME."
I apologize for anyone who somehow remembers this game it was actually Capuano who dueled with Smoltz. o and Frenchy absolutely hosed the crap out some Brewer who clearly didnt realize it was Jeff Francoeur in right. I called it before the ball landed in the glove, becuase my dad had said that the brewers had got a run, i replied “NU UH”
ooo i miss that Jeff guy.
"The game doesn't stink Mr. Wheeler. It's a GREAT GAME."
hahaha
I get it. Pretend that Frenchy isn’t even on the team anymore. That’s what true fan would do. Good stuff!
"You never know what I'm going to do..."
- Michael Vick (Palm Beach Post 11/6/2005)
The DH is just wrong, flat out
People who want the DH to appear in the NL probably also want pitchers to hone their skills, focus on a few pitches, and commit to pitching only for 4 years, so that they can throw all their future out along with their arm for one inning of relief.
Its funny though, set-up men and specialty relievers are newish too. They also compromise the integrity of the game. I hate the fact that people are groomed for one inning of play. But it happens, and I have to accept it. Most likely the DH WILL come to the NL, we should probably start thinking about it anyway.

by 





















